Required Practical 6 – Chromatography

Emmanuel Opoku

Teacher

Emmanuel Opoku

Aim

Investigate the coloured components of a mixture using chromatography by comparison to known colours.

General Scientific Background

Chromatography is used to separate mixtures and help identify substances. Different chemicals have:

  • Different solubilities in the solvent

  • Different attractions to the chromatography paper

So they separate and travel different distances → creating separate spots.

A chemical that is more soluble in the solvent will travel further up the paper.
A chemical that is more strongly attracted to the paper will travel a shorter distance.

To compare substances we calculate the Rf value:

Rf values are always between 0 – 1, and substances with identical Rf values in the same solvent are likely to be the same compound.

Pure vs Impure Substances in Chromatography

Chromatography is a powerful way to test the purity of a substance.

✔ Pure substances

A pure substance contains only one chemical, so on a chromatogram it produces:

  • Only ONE spot in a vertical column above the sample.

  • No matter how many times the experiment is repeated.

  • And the spot appears in the same position each time (same Rf value).

✔ Impure substances (mixtures)

A mixture contains more than one chemical, so it will produce:

  • Two or more spots in a vertical column above the sample.

  • Each with its own Rf value.

  • Showing that the substance is made of different components.

Variables

Independent variable

Type of dye (A, B, C, D, X - unknown).

Dependent variable

Distance moved by each dye (mm) → used to calculate Rf.

Controlled variables

  • Solvent volume

  • Solvent type

  • Size of the chromatography paper

  • Starting spot size

  • Same pencil baseline height

  • Temperature of solvent

Apparatus

  • 250 cm³ beaker

  • Glass rod/wooden splint

  • Chromatography paper

  • Capillary tubes

  • Solvent (e.g. water/ethanol)

  • Known food colours (Sample 1–6)

  • Unknown sample (X)

  • Pencil

  • Ruler

  • Lid (to stop solvent from evaporating)

Method

1. Draw a horizontal pencil line 2 cm from the bottom of the chromatography paper.
Mark five pencil spots evenly spaced along the line.

2. Use capillary tubes to place small spots of food colouring 1–6 and X onto the pencil marks (each spot < 5 mm diameter). Allow to dry.

3. Pour water (solvent) into a beaker to a depth of no more than 1 cm.

4. Attach the top of the chromatography paper to a glass rod/wooden split using tape/paper clip and hang it in the beaker so:

  • the baseline is above the solvent,

  • the paper does not touch the sides.

5. Place the lid over the top of the beaker and leave the chromatogram until the solvent front travels about ¾ up the paper. Do not disturb the beaker.

6. Remove the paper and immediately mark the wet solvent front with pencil.

7. Allow the paper to dry and measure the following:

  • Distance moved by solvent (baseline → solvent front).

  • Distance moved by each spot (baseline → centre of each spot).

8. Calculate Rf values using:

Example Chromatogram and Results Table

Sample

Colour

Distance (mm)

Solvent Distance (mm)

Rf

X

orange

70

80

0.88

X

red (middle)

30

80

0.38

1

brown

45

80

0.56

2

orange

70

80

0.88

3

red (middle)

30

80

0.38

4

orange

70

80

0.88

4

blue

10

80

0.13

5

red (middle)

30

80

0.38

5

red (low)

20

80

0.25

6

brown

45

80

0.56

 

Conclusion: What Does X Contain?

X contains two substances:

  • Orange (Rf 0.88)

  • Red-medium (Rf 0.38)

✔ Substances that match X:

Substance in X

Matches With

Orange (0.88)

2, 4

Red (0.38)

3, 5

X Does one sample contain BOTH components of X?

No.

  • Samples 2 and 4 have the orange spot, but not the red (middle height). And 4 has an extra blue spot which is not in X.

  • Samples 3 and 5 have the medium red, but not the orange and sample 5 has an extra red spot (low height).

➡ Therefore: No sample fully matches X but it is a mixture of 2 and 3.

Main Sources of Error in Chromatography

Error

Effect

Baseline drawn inink/ pen

Ink dissolves and contaminates results (shifts all Rf values)

Solvent level above baseline

Spots dissolve into solvent → all results invalid

 

Practice Questions

Recall

A) What two phases are involved in paper chromatography?

A) Stationary phase = chromatography paper, mobile phase = solvent.

B) What does a pure substance look like on a chromatogram?

B) One spot above the sample in a vertical column.

C) What does Rf stand for?

C) Retention factor.

Apply

D. A spot travels 15 mm and the solvent travels 45 mm. Calculate Rf.

D) Rf = 15/45 =0.33

E. A chromatogram shows three spots for a food dye sample. Is it pure or impure? Explain.

E) Impure – more than one spot in a vertical column above the sample.

F. Two substances have Rf values of 0.33 and 0.67. Which is more soluble in the solvent?

F) The spot with Rf = 0.67 (moves further → more soluble).

Challenge

G) Explain why pencil must be used instead of pen.

G) Pen ink dissolves in solvent and interferes with the results.

H) A student draws the baseline in ink. Predict how this affects the results.

H) Ink dissolves and produces extra spots → cannot identify the sample.

I) Why do different solvents produce different Rf values for the same substance?

I) Different solvents change solubility and strength of attraction → altering how far substances travel.